Together and Apart


You must sign in to view content.

Sign In

Sign In

Sign Up

The Religious Experience of Homeless People in Drug Use Scenes

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session
Camila Chagas  

Religiosity is often analyzed as a variable that would reduce the chances of drug use. However, there is a gap in the literature on the analysis of other roles that religiosity can play in people's lives. An ethnography was conducted in Portugal from November 2022 to August 2023 in drug use scenes in the city of Porto. Our purpose was to understand whether (and how) religiosity would be present in vulnerable psychotropic territories. It was possible to observe elements of religiosity that would go unnoticed in the face of the evident social and psychological fragilities in the territories. The homeless population is immersed in spaces of exclusion, places that belong to everyone and no one. These environments are also capable of producing their own religious experiences. These adaptations can occur in the commitment to one's own religiosity, which ceases to encompass the collective and becomes solitary. Thus, religiosity in these marginalized contexts is perhaps one of the few constant elements in the lives of these actors. While everything changes depending on the will of others, such as displacement from a place due to police intervention, and uncertainty regarding food or safety, the subjective protection of religiosity can be a means of providing stability and control. This subjective protection has also been shown to be a risk factor insofar as it increases the feeling of security in situations with a high risk of communicable diseases and overdose. Religiosity can therefore be a source of certainty in a world of uncertainty.

The Vulnerability of Jewish Patients in Medical Halakhah (Jewish Law)

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session
Sarah Werren  

Issues of life, death, and social justice have been questions long pondered by philosophers and theologians, including Jewish scholars from all branches of Judaism. Their conclusions to answering unprecedented ethical problems became an integral part of the new evaluation of medical practice and health policy since World War II. Consequently, one of the cornerstones of modern medicine is patient autonomy; a concept not entirely commensurable with Jewish Orthodox practice, which tends to limit autonomous decision-making that is not authorized by halakhic (religion-legal) authorities. This is due to the modus operandi of Orthodox Jewish bioethics, which is halakhic in nature. Jewish law is the frame of reference within which religious authorities discuss, analyze and decide what may be otherwise known as an ethics case. This paper discusses the vulnerability of Jewish patients in restrictive religious contexts that control personal decision-making processes in every area of life. Based on empirical research and interviews with rabbis we address the following questions: how do hegemonial religious structures affect the vulnerability (or resilience) of Jewish patients? What is the scope of personal freedom in decision-making of an observant Jew in situations of unbearable pain and suffering? As a matter of fact, halakhic authorities are considered to rule leniently in medical cases, since patients are especially vulnerable and it is forbidden to add suffering. Within the scope of these questions, we give special attention to the proverbial phrase „Lev yodea marat nafsho,“ the heart knows its own bitterness (Proverbs 14.10), in medical Halakhah.

Digital Media

Discussion board not yet opened and is only available to registered participants.